Imagine a place where up to 250 guests can enjoy stunning marina views. Welcome to Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering Menu, the top spot for waterfront dining on the South Shore of Long Island. For 25 years, we’ve been serving up delicious meals with a mix of old charm and new flavors.
At the beautiful Bay Shore Marina, our menu is a taste of Long Island’s coast. You’ll find everything from fresh seafood to top-quality steaks. We make sure there’s something for everyone to love.
Looking for a special meal? Captain Bills is your go-to for dinners, lunches, or brunches. Our place offers amazing views, tasty dishes, and friendly service. It’s why locals have been coming here for years.
Want to see what we’re all about? Call us at (555) 123-4567 or check our website. Book your table and see why Captain Bills is a favorite on Long Island.
Important Links for Captain Bill’s Restaurant & Catering Menu
| Category | Link |
|---|---|
| Home | captainbills.com |
| Upcoming Specials | Upcoming Specials |
| Catering Plated Menu | Catering Plated Menu |
| Catering About | Catering About |
| Catering Event Spaces | Catering Event Spaces |
| Catering Brunch | Catering Brunch |
| Catering Gallery | Catering Gallery |
The Official Social Media Links for Captain Bill’s
| Platform | Link |
|---|---|
| facebook.com/captainbillsbayshore | |
| instagram.com/captainbillsbayshore | |
| TikTok | tiktok.com/@captainbillsbayshore |
Contact Details
| Category | Details |
|---|---|
| Business Name | Captain Bill’s Restaurant & Catering |
| Address | 122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 |
| Phone Number | (631) 665-6262 |
| events@captainbills.com | |
| Website | captainbills.com |
General Operating Hours for Captain Bill’s
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | Lunch: 12:00–3:45 PM<br>Dinner: 4:30–9:00 PM |
| Tuesday | Lunch: 12:00–3:45 PM<br>Dinner: 4:30–9:00 PM |
| Wednesday | Lunch: 12:00–3:45 PM<br>Dinner: 4:30–9:00 PM |
| Thursday | Lunch: 12:00–3:45 PM<br>Dinner: 4:30–9:00 PM |
| Friday | Lunch: 12:00–3:45 PM<br>Dinner: 4:30–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | Lunch: 12:00–3:30 PM<br>Dinner: 4:30–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | Brunch: 11:30 AM–2:30 PM<br>Dinner: 4:00–8:30 PM |
Bar menu available all day. Happy Hour offered Tuesday–Friday from 4:00–7:00 PM.
The Rich History of Captain Bill’s Waterfront Restaurant
Captain Bill’s Restaurant sits by the scenic waterfront. It has a story of food tradition and overcoming challenges. It started in the late 1920s with a small wooden building that became famous.
From Humble Clam Bar to Waterfront Legend
The restaurant began as a small clam bar run by the Boatmen’s Association. Key moments helped it grow:
- Early 1950s: Sophie and Carl Abendroth bought it, leading to big changes
- Late 1950s: They bought the Anchorage catering hall, opening up new possibilities
- Late 1980s: Big renovations gave it a new life
Legacy of Excellence
Despite tough times, Captain Bill’s kept going strong. A big renovation in 1998 marked a new beginning.
Modern Leadership and Growth
In 2018, Kelly Kiernan took over as managing partner. She brought new energy and kept the high standards. Her leadership has kept the restaurant’s good name alive.
By 2023, Captain Bill’s celebrated 25 years of being open again. It shows its lasting charm and dedication to great food.
Captain Bill’s Restaurant & Catering Menu (2025) – Prices & Details
Captain Bill’s takes you on a culinary journey through Long Island’s South Shore. Our menu is a mix of seafood and steaks, perfect for everyone. It’s designed to give you a top-notch dining experience.
Signature Seafood Selections
Our seafood comes straight from local waters. You’ll find a variety of fresh catches that bring the coast to your plate:
- Fresh daily oysters
- Local catch of the day
- Classic clam preparations
- Seasonal seafood specials
| Seafood Specialty | Description | Price Range |
|---|---|---|
| Oyster Platter | Freshly shucked local oysters | $24-$36 |
| Local Fish Filet | Seasonally selected fresh catch | $28-$42 |
Premium Aged Steaks and Prime Ribs
Premium steaks are a big part of our menu. Our chefs pick and age the steaks to make them juicy and full of flavor:
- USDA Prime ribeye
- Dry-aged New York strip
- Tender prime rib
| Steak Cut | Aging Process | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Prime Ribeye | 21-day dry-aged | $45 |
| New York Strip | 28-day dry-aged | $42 |
Special Dietary Accommodations
We’re all about making sure everyone has a great meal. Our kitchen can handle different diets, like:
- Gluten-free options
- Vegetarian selections
- Low-sodium preparations
- Custom dietary modifications
“Our goal is to ensure every guest enjoys a memorable meal that meets their individual needs.” – Chef Michael Korb
Elegant Event Spaces and Waterfront Views
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering Menu offers amazing waterfront event spaces. These spaces make every event unforgettable. Located on the South Shore of Long Island, the venue has stunning views of the Bay Shore Marina.
The restaurant has event rooms for all group sizes. Whether it’s a small gathering or a big celebration, there’s a space for you. You can choose from three unique areas:
- Waterview Room – Great for small, personal events
- Harborview Room – Best for medium-sized groups
- Bayview House – Amazing for large events up to 250 guests
Each room has special features and beautiful marina views. The Bayview House, updated in 1998, shows Captain Bill’s dedication to creating special event spaces.
| Event Space | Capacity | Best Suited For |
|---|---|---|
| Waterview Room | 30-50 guests | Private parties, corporate meetings |
| Harborview Room | 75-150 guests | Weddings, larger celebrations |
| Bayview House | 150-250 guests | Large weddings, corporate events |
“Our waterfront event spaces are more than just rooms – they’re canvases for creating unforgettable memories.” – Captain Bill’s Event Coordinator
With nearly a century of experience, Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering Menu offers top-notch event spaces. These spaces capture the beauty of Long Island’s maritime charm.
Exclusive Catering Services and Special Events
Captain Bill’s Restaurant & Catering Menu offers a unique experience for those looking for top-notch catering and special events. With over 20 years of experience, our team is dedicated to creating unforgettable moments.
Our catering services aim to make any event a memorable one. Whether it’s a corporate meeting, wedding, or private party, Captain Bill’s ensures culinary excellence and professional event support.
Customizable Menu Options
Guests can choose from a wide range of menu options. Our chefs create personalized dining experiences that meet individual tastes and dietary needs:
- Seafood specialties featuring fresh local ingredients
- Premium steak and prime rib selections
- Vegetarian and gluten-free accommodations
- Custom appetizer and entree combinations
Professional Event Planning Support
Our event coordination team offers full support for your special events. We handle everything from the first meeting to the final event, ensuring a smooth process.
Capacity and Room Specifications
Captain Bill’s has versatile event spaces for all sizes. Our venues can hold up to 250 guests, making them perfect for both small dinners and big celebrations.
| Event Type | Capacity | Recommended Space |
|---|---|---|
| Corporate Events | 50-200 guests | Bayview House |
| Weddings | 100-250 guests | Main Catering Hall |
| Private Parties | 25-150 guests | Anchorage Room |
With stunning views of the Bay Shore Marina and a focus on culinary excellence, Captain Bill’s Restaurant & Catering Menu is ready to make your events unforgettable.
Operating Hours and Contact Information
Find Captain Bill’s Restaurant & Catering Menu in Bay Shore, a prime location. Our team is here to help with dining reservations or event planning at 122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706. Call us at (631) 665-6262 or email events@captainbills.com for any questions about our hours or services.
Our hours are set for lunch and dinner, with changes for the seasons. We can host intimate dinners or big events for up to 250 guests. Our staff is dedicated to making your visit special. Follow us on social media for updates and offers.
Need to plan an event or book a table? You can reach us in several ways. Call our direct line or email us for a quick reply. Captain Bill’s has been serving Bay Shore for 25 years, with top-notch dining and catering.
We can’t wait to welcome you at Captain Bill’s. Here, 25 years of cooking tradition meet modern service. Our team is eager to give you a memorable dining experience, celebrating our maritime heritage and service excellence.
